What is wrong here?
The ability to write mixed fractions as improper fractions and vice versa is an important pre-requisite to adding and subtracting mixed fractions (CCSS.Math.4.NF.3c):
Add and subtract mixed numbers with like denominators, e.g., by replacing each mixed number with an equivalent fraction, and/or by using properties of operations and the relationship between addition and subtraction. – (CCSS.Math.4.NF.3c)
Fractions, to many students, is a set of rules and procedures. Very often, we find students changing fractions to the same denominator when they are multiplying, or adding numerators and denominators separately. In writing mixed numbers as improper fractions, many students resort to memorizing procedures too, and the above example is one of the many mistakes that students make. “Do I multiply the whole with the numerator or the denominator?”, “Do I need to add the numerator after multiplying?”
One problem could be the over emphasis on procedural over conceptual understanding. Instead of starting the topic with rules, why not let the students induce the pattern by themselves?
Discussion and Suggestion
How and when should we introduce “writing mixed numbers as improper fractions”?
If we look at the US Common Core standards carefully, the ability to write mixed numbers as improper fractions and vice versa is not explicitly stated anywhere. Instead, it is subtly mentioned as one example in CCSS.Math.4.NF.3b:
Decompose a fraction into a sum of fractions with the same denominator in more than one way, recording each decomposition by an equation. Justify decompositions, e.g., by using a visual fraction model. Examples: 3/8 = 1/8 + 1/8 + 1/8 ; 3/8 = 1/8 + 2/8 ; 2 1/8 = 1 + 1 + 1/8 = 8/8 + 8/8 + 1/8.- (CCSS.Math.4.NF.3b)
We like the way this is laid out in the overall curriculum. Writing mixed numbers as improper fractions should be viewed as part of decomposing fractions, e.g. by representing the whole number as an equivalent fraction.
This can easily progress to decomposing mixed numbers into its parts.
Similar examples can be found in the Math In Focus workbooks, e.g.
Singapore Math (Math in Focus Workbook 4A)
Note that in the above examples, writing mixed numbers as improper fraction is introduced pictorially and very often, students are able to deduce their own rules of “changing” mixed numbers to improper fractions, after going through these exercises.
The ability to write mixed fractions as improper fractions should be taught conceptually. This topic provides an excellent teachable moment for students to reason and induce rules on their own. Instead of starting the topic with rules and procedures, try giving students time to explore and have a go at what mathematicians do!
This article is part of a series of blog posts on Fractions:
- >> Read the next post on Fractions: Addition and Subtraction of Fractions Part 1 – Like Fractions
- << Read the previous post on Fractions: On Comparing Fractions
- Or start from the beginning: Understanding Fractions as Equal Parts
More Fraction Resources
For more fraction resources, refer to our main fractions page.