Understanding the Concept of Same Whole in Fractions

Last week, we wrote about the importance of understanding fractions as equal parts. Of equal importance is the concept of the same whole in fractions. Fundamentally, fractions is only fully defined if the whole is specified. In the following example, without specifying what the whole is, it is not reasonable to ask what fraction is represented by the shaded area.

Fractions - same whole
Fractions – same whole

If each of the square is a “whole”, the shaded area represents the fraction 3/2. If the entire rectangle is the whole, the shaded area represents 3/4.

To emphasize the importance of specifying the whole, we can include a definition of the whole as the first step when working on exercises in naming fractions, e.g.

Practice defining the whole when naming fractions
Practice defining the whole when naming fractions

Now that we have this fundamental definition out of the way, let’s talk about why understanding the concept of having the “same whole” is so important in two aspects of learning about fractions.

1. Comparing Fractions

Fractions have to be compared based on the same-sized unit, i.e. the “same whole”. From the Common Core Standards:

Compare two fractions with the same numerator or the same denominator by reasoning about their size. Recognize that comparisons are valid only when the two fractions refer to the same whole. – (CCSS.Math.3.NF.3d)

Compare two fractions with different numerators and different denominators, e.g., by creating common denominators or numerators, or by comparing to a benchmark fraction such as 1/2. Recognize that comparisons are valid only when the two fractions refer to the same whole. – (CCSS.Math.4.NF.2)

The following example is quoted from this excellent book on fractions by Dr Douglas Edge and Dr Yeap Ban Har – Teaching to Mastery Mathematics: Teaching of Fractions.

Which is more, 1/2 or 1/3?

Compare different fractions
Compare different fractions

The shaded area appears to be bigger in the right figure for 1/3 than the left figure for 1/2, but the fraction 1/3 is smaller than 1/2. To compare these two fractions pictorially, we need to draw them on the same base shape with the same area, e.g. using rectangles,

Comparing fractions using same whole
Comparing fractions using the same whole

In the same sense, while 1/2 is more than 1/3, “1/2 of my salary can be less than 1/3 of yours”.

2. Adding and Subtracting Fractions

Adding and subtracting fractions can also be presented pictorially (CCSS.Math.5.NF.2). However, care must be taken to explain that the addition and subtraction is referring to the same whole.

Solve word problems involving addition and subtraction of fractions referring to the same whole, including cases of unlike denominators, e.g., by using visual fraction models or equations to represent the problem. – (CCSS.Math.5.NF.s)

A common mistake is explained in the following example.

Adding two fractions - different whole
Wrong example:  Adding fractions

1/4 + 1/4 is not 2/8, but it is easy to see how students can make this mistake if they count the total shaded squares and use it as the numerator, then count the number of equal parts and use it as the denominator. If we represent the two fractions as referring to the same unit, this error would be avoided.

Adding fractions - same whole
Correct example: Adding fractions

Conclusion

While visual models are useful, care must be taken to present them correctly, otherwise it will only add confusion to our students. In drawing models for fractions, we need to emphasize the importance of the “same whole” when they are used for instruction on fraction comparison, addition and subtraction. This concept of referencing the same unit in fractions, along with that of “equal parts“, are both fundamental in helping students understand the meaning of fractions. These concepts will go a long way when students learn about fractions on the number line and equivalent fractions, which we will write about in the coming weeks.

Note: Some of the links on this blog post are affiliate links, if you click on it and purchase, we will earn a small percentage of the sale at no additional cost to you.


This article is part of a series of blog posts on Fractions:


More Fraction Resources

For more fraction resources, refer to our main fractions page.

4 thoughts on “Understanding the Concept of Same Whole in Fractions”

  1. Really glad I stumbled across your website. Yes, a big concept is that we can only compare fractions when the wholes are the same…beautifully demonstrated by the images. However, does this also apply in situations e.g. 3 out of 4 of Ellie’s pencils are red. Image of 3 red pencils and one other (3/4) and Tim has 5 red pencils out of 7 (5/7). Who has the greatest fraction? Can this be compared because you can make the quantities the ‘same’ by making equivalent fractions? 21/28 and 20/28 or not because because the original wholes are different? I may not be seeing the obvious here. Thanks.

    1. Hi Jill, we love this question! We tried to write our reply here but it got too long, so we wrote another blog post to explain. See here for our long-winded reply. Thank you for asking this question!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top